The Private Eye by Brian K. Vaughan


Leggi questo articolo in italiano

One day the cloud ripped and everybody’s secrets were secrets no more.

The generation following this event uses Internet no more, secret identities are legal and helped by masks and disguises. The police force is now the press.

A private investigator is hired by a girl who is found dead one day later. The P.I. life changes as he is involved in an intrigue with potential catastrophic consequences.

The themes behind the story are current news (the use of the web, anonymity, privacy issues,..), the story is useful to think about how few awareness we have about the much we concede to the web and what is actually private (Remember when, on the Internet, nobody knew who you were?).

The book has a nice rhythm, interesting characters and a well-built setting, honestly it was some time since a comic engaged me as much. The book collects the whole series of 10 episodes.

* The Private Eye by Brian K. Vaughan ★★★★☆

*I read this book in italian

Memory of Water by Emmi Itäranta


Leggi questo articolo in Italiano

The publication of the Hunger Games series shaped the dystopia fiction for young adults, and as consequence we have similar, unoriginal, novels. For this reason Memory of Water by Emmi Itäranta, a finnish author.  seemed to be something original in this scenario.

The novel’s main character, Noria Kaitio, is learning the Tea Master’s art from her father, the Tea Master of their village, in the New Qian state.

In the future when the story is set water is a luxury good, and the distribution is up to the military regime. Noria’s father guards a water spring, and keeps it hidden from the village people and the soldiers; the change of the officers managing the village area will worsen the village situation, and Noria’s family will have to be more careful to keep the spring hidden.

In the end I was disappointed from the novel, mainly for the choice to tell a story set in a culture different from the author’s. The oriental society is quite approximated in their social structures and the Tea art is the only strong feature of the oriental setting. This art was interesting, but it somehow simplify excessively the Chinese culture.

The novel tries too much to be evocative in ideas and narration, but the main result is a main character unperturbed by everything happens to her – this follows the idea of the personification of water, but the narration ends up to be not so much engaging.


Memory of Water by Emmi Itäranta ★★★☆

*I read this book in English


[ARC] Only Ever Yours by Louise O’Neill


Leggi questo articolo in italiano

Unspecified and uninfluential climatic disasters made the world Louise O’Neill talks about; the countries collapsed in the Zones (European, American and Chindia), macro-areas that group the residual population, the story is set in the European Zone, but the way they work is standard.

In the Zones the population evolution is controlled, the society, now clearly misogynist, allows only male child to be born, them destined to inherit their fathers activities and to manage everything (from production, commerce, law, and government), while women are genetically created towards an aesthetic ideal to satisfy better men taste.

The eves, as the women category is defined, grow up in schools where they learn to do make up, to dress, to compete to be the most beautiful (and there is always room for improvement), where they always take drugs to sleep, to have a better skin, to maintain the correct body weight,… Their education (that of course does not cover reading, to avoid unprogrammed ambitions) ends at their 16th year, when they meet the men of their age that will be able to choose their companions.

After the Ceremony the eves can be a become few things: they can be companions, so wives, so mothers – and if they don’t there is the risk of they are substituted, by the way they do not last after being forty, since aging is ugly – or concubines that satisfy every need, or chastities that teach in the eves schools. Or, last and most unlikely chance, they can be sent underworld to be studied in case of malfunctioning, in order to correct the future generation of eves.

Only ever yours is the story of frieda, an eve at her last year (and yeah, their value is so little their names do not deserve the capital letter), and she has to face come changes: in addition to the tension for the last year of school – and the perspective to meet the Inheritants – frieda tries to maintain her friendship with isabel, the most beautiful eve of frieda’s group, always first in the rankings, who lately has very strange behaviours, like she’s trying self-destruction.

frieda is in the middle between the love for her friend and the desire to belong to the group of the most popular eves, who always envied isabel and who are ready to bully her whenever they find a way. And while frieda’s world seems to shatter the last year goes on and the guys come to meet the girls.

Only ever yours is an engaging novel that does not makes space for happiness, not because it tells fake and evil things, but because it takes to extreme real and true things. On one side the idea of women as wives and mothers or whores, without taking into account ambitions, desires and emotions; in the novel the eves are something to own and to trow away when they are not interesting anymore.

On the other the envy, the evil comments made at the back of other girls, because she is too fat, she is too thin, how that color poorly suits her, how did she dress, I would be better in that dress, am I beautiful enough, am I thin enough, I have to eat less, look at my thighs, look at my hairs,… because sometimes it happened also to us to make comment and to envy and to compare ourselves with the models, sometimes wrong, that are proposed us.

Only ever yours is a dramatic novel that however could help thinking about what we are and what we would actually be.

Thanks to the publisher for providing me the copy necessary to write this review.

* Only Ever Yours by Louise O’Neill ★★★★

*I read this book in english

The Melancholy of Mechagirl by Catherynne M. Valente


Leggi questo articolo in Italiano

TOC – Table of contents

  • The melancholy of mechagirl
  • Ink, water, milk
  • Fifteen panels depicting the sadness of the baku and the jotai
  • Ghosts of Gunkanjima
  • Thirteen ways of looking at space/time
  • One breath, one stroke
  • Story no. 6
  • Fade to white
  • The emperor of Tsukayama park
  • Killswitch
  • Memoirs of a girl who failed to be born from a peach
  • The girl with two skins
  • Silently and very fast

The second short stories group reading – after “At the mouth of the river of bees” – was based on the collection of poems and stories about Japan by Catherynne M. Valente, “The Melancholy of Mechagirl”.

Continue reading